Poisoned by Friendly Fire
By Juan Gonzalez
Four soldiers from a New York Army National Guard company serving in Iraq are contaminated with radiation likely caused by dust from depleted uranium shells fired by U.S. troops, a Daily News investigation has found.
They are among several members of the same company, the 442nd Military Police, who say they have been battling persistent physical ailments that began last summer in the Iraqi town of Samawah.
I got sick instantly in June, said Staff Sgt. Ray Ramos, a Brooklyn housing cop. My health kept going downhill with daily headaches, constant numbness in my hands and rashes on my stomach.
A nuclear medicine expert who examined and tested nine soldiers from the company says that four almost certainly inhaled radioactive dust from exploded American shells manufactured with depleted uranium.
Laboratory tests conducted at the request of The News revealed traces of two manmade forms of uranium in urine samples from four of the soldiers.
If so, the menSgt. Hector Vega, Sgt. Ray Ramos, Sgt. Agustin Matos and Cpl. Anthony Yonnoneare the first confirmed cases of inhaled depleted uranium exposure from the current Iraq conflict.
The 442nd, made up for the most part of New York cops, firefighters and correction officers, is based in Orangeburg, Rockland County. Dispatched to Iraq last Easter, the units members have been providing guard duty for convoys, running jails and training Iraqi police. The entire company is due to return home later this month.
These are amazing results, especially since these soldiers were military police not exposed to the heat of battle, said Dr. Asaf Duracovic, who examined the G.I.s and performed the testing that was funded by The News.
Other American soldiers who were in combat must have more depleted uranium exposure, said Duracovic, a colonel in the Army Reserves who served in the 1991 Persian Gulf War.
While working at a military hospital in Delaware, he was one of the first doctors to discover unusual radiation levels in Gulf War veterans. He has since become a leading critic of the use of depleted uranium in warfare.
Depleted uranium, a waste product of the uranium enrichment process, has been used by the U.S. and British military for more than 15 years in some artillery shells and as armor plating for tanks. It is twice as heavy as lead.
Because of its density, It is the superior heavy metal for armor to protect tanks and to penetrate armor, Pentagon spokesman Michael Kilpatrick said.
The Army and Air Force fired at least 127 tons of depleted uranium shells in Iraq last year, Kilpatrick said. No figures have yet been released for how much the Marines fired.
Kilpatrick said about 1,000 GIs back from the war have been tested by the Pentagon for depleted uranium and only three have come up positiveall as a result of shrapnel from DU shells.
But the test results for the New York guardsmenfour of nine positives for DUsuggest the potential for more extensive radiation exposure among coalition troops and Iraqi civilians.
Several Army studies in recent years have concluded that the low-level radiation emitted when shells containing DU explode poses no significant dangers. But some independent scientists and a few of the Armys own reports indicate otherwise.
As a result, depleted uranium weapons have sparked increasing controversy around the world. In January 2003, the European Parliament called for a moratorium on their use after reports of an unusual number of leukemia deaths among Italian soldiers who served in Kosovo, where DU weapons were used.
I keep getting weaker. What is happening to me?
The Army says that only soldiers wounded by depleted uranium shrapnel or who are inside tanks during an explosion face measurable radiation exposure.
But as far back as 1979, Leonard Dietz, a physicist at the Knolls Atomic Power Laboratory upstate, discovered that DU-contaminated dust could travel for long distances.
Dietz, who pioneered the technology to isolate uranium isotopes, accidentally discovered that air filters with which he was experimenting had collected radioactive dust from a National Lead Industries Plant that was producing DU 26 miles away. His discovery led to a shutdown of the plant.
The contamination was so heavy that they had to remove the topsoil from 52 properties around the plant, Dietz said.
All humans have at least tiny amounts of natural uranium in their bodies because it is found in water and in the food supply, Dietz said. But natural uranium is quickly and harmlessly excreted by the body.
Uranium oxide dust, which lodges in the lungs once inhaled and is not very soluble, can emit radiation to the body for years.
Anybody, civilian or soldier, who breathes these particles has a permanent dose, and its not going to decrease very much over time, said Dietz, who retired in 1983 after 33 years as nuclear physicist. In the long run...veterans exposed to ceramic uranium oxide have a major problem.
Critics of DU have noted that the Armys view of its dangers has changed over time.
Before the 1991 Persian Gulf War, a 1990 Army report noted that depleted uranium is linked to cancer when exposures are internal, [and] chemical toxicity causing kidney damage.
It was during the Gulf War that U.S. A-10 Warthog tank buster planes and Abrams tanks first used DU artillery on a mass scale. The Pentagon says it fired about 320 tons of DU in that war and that smaller amounts were also used in the Serbian province of Kosovo.
In the Gulf War, Army brass did not warn soldiers about any risks from exploding DU shells. An unknown number of G.I.s were exposed by shrapnel, inhalation or handling battlefield debris.
Some veterans groups blame DU contamination as a factor in Gulf War syndrome, the term for a host of ailments that afflicted thousands of vets from that war.
Under pressure from veterans groups, the Pentagon commissioned several new studies. One of those, published in 2000, concluded that DU, as a heavy metal, could pose a chemical hazard but that Gulf War veterans did not experience intakes high enough to affect their health.
Pentagon spokesman Michael Kilpatrick said Army follow-up studies of 70 DU-contaminated Gulf War veterans have not shown serious health effects.
For any heavy metal, there is no such thing as safe, Kilpatrick said. There is an issue of chemical toxicity, and for DU it is raised as radiological toxicity as well.
But he said the overwhelming conclusion from studies of those who work with uranium show it has not produced any increase in cancers.
Several European studies, however, have linked DU to chromosome damage and birth defects in mice. Many scientists say we still dont know enough about the long-range effects of low-level radiation on the body to say any amount is safe.
Britains national science academy, the Royal Society, has called for identifying where DU was used and is urging a cleanup of all contaminated areas.
A large number of American soldiers [in Iraq] may have had significant exposure to uranium oxide dust, said Dr. Thomas Fasey, a pathologist at Mount Sinai Medical Center and an expert on depleted uranium. And the health impact is worrisome for the future.
As for the soldiers of the 442nd, theyre sick, frustrated and confused. They say when they arrived in Iraq no one warned them about depleted uranium and no one gave them dust masks.
Experts behind probe
As part of the investigation by the Daily News, Dr. Asaf Duracovic, a nuclear medicine expert who has conducted extensive research on depleted uranium, examined the nine soldiers from the 442nd Military Police in late December and collected urine specimens from each.
Another member of his team, Prof. Axel Gerdes, a geologist at Goethe University in Frankfurt who specializes in analyzing uranium isotopes, performed repeated tests on the samples over a week-long period. He used a state-of-the art procedure called multiple collector, inductively coupled, plasma-mass spectrometry.
Only about 100 laboratories worldwide have the same capability to identify and measure various uranium isotopes in minute quantities, Gerdes said.
Gerdes concluded that four of the men had depleted uranium in their bodies. Depleted uranium, which does not occur in nature, is created as a waste product of uranium enrichment when some of the highly radioactive isotopes in natural uranium, U-235 and U-234, are extracted.
Several of the men, according to Duracovic, also had minute traces of another uranium isotope, U-236, that is produced only in a nuclear reaction process.
These men were almost certainly exposed to radioactive weapons on the battlefield, Duracovic said.
He and Gerdes plan to issue a scientific paper on their study of the soldiers at the annual meeting of the European Association of Nuclear Medicine in Finland this year.
When DU shells explode, they permanently contaminate their target and the area immediately around it with low-level radioactivity.
Daily News, April 3, 2004